MacBook Pro Good and Bad

My employer just upgraded my MacBook Pro from the old 2006 model to the latest 2.66 GHz Intel Core i7 with 8GB or 1067 MHz DDR3 RAM.  I’ve noticed some pros and cons about it so far…

Pros

  • High-def screen is crystal clear 1680×1050 compared to my old 1440×900.
  • Glass screen has eye popping brightness and contrast.
  • After Effects is blazing fast compared to my old machine.  This machine is actually worthy of video and 3D work!
  • SD Card slot!
  • Uses the same power adapter!
  • Side-loading CD/DVD
  • True multi-touch pad
  • Body casing design is much better.  If you need to upgrade you can access the critical components much easier.
  • New mini-display port supports HDMI although there are lots of complaints about different adapters not supporting audio through it.
  • It’s heavy!  Not sure if this is a pro or a con.  Noticeably heavier than my old machine.  Maybe it just feels heavier because it’s so frickin’ solid?

Cons

  • Glare.  I opted for the glass screen with the expectation that it would have better color.  It does have much better color but I already miss my old matte screen because the glare is unbelievable on this thing.  I can definitely work with it but I’m constantly adjusting the screen angle.
  • Crappy speakers! The biggest problem is that these speakers will tire your ears in a matter of a few minutes.  I can’t believe how bad these speakers sound compared to my old MacBook Pro!  I can’t believe they are part of an Apple product!  They are undeserving of the name.  They are very tinny and harsh sounding.  That said, I am a big time audiophile so I’m probably more sensitive to this than most people.  I tried tweaking the EQ in iTunes and discovered that these speakers have little to no response below about 115 Hz.  Horrible bass response.
    UPDATE: I finally got around to plugging this in to my TV via HDMI.  I was very disapointed to find that the sound quality was just as crappy as the speakers on the laptop itself.  Interestingly it sounds like it has the exact same issues, tinny and harsh sounding.  I know that my TV sounds great most of the time so I can now eliminate the Mac speakers as the issue.  It’s got to be either software or hardware processing because the headphone jack spits out great quality sound.
  • Ultra light sensitive.  The screen is constantly adjusting brightness based on ambient light.  The variations are dramatic to where it bothers my eyes.  I will probably have to disable this feature in the preferences.
  • It has a mini-display port instead of a direct DVI.  This means that you have to purchase the new adapters.  Yes that’s plural.  If you hook up to a DVI in one location and a VGA or HDMI in another you’ll need 2 or 3 adapters at $30 a pop!  That really sucks.
  • It’s heavy!  Not sure if this is a pro or a con.  Noticeably heavier than my old machine.  Maybe it just feels heavier because it’s so frickin’ solid?
  • Keyboard arrows aren’t labeled with home, end, page up and page down (although they still work as expected).  This is helpful when remote controlling a windows machine with RDC.

6 Replies to “MacBook Pro Good and Bad”

  1. HDMI is the only way to go. So hopefully Apple has it right.

    I would add to the Cons list that it does not support Blu-ray read or write. If someone going to pay that much money for a MacBook, it better have Blu-ray. Plus, Apple considers itself top of the line and up to date with technology – supposedly.

    Good thing you did not pay for this machine. It probably is still awesome anyways – even more so free.

  2. It is definitely a very nice machine. I’m not really sold on the blu-ray thing yet. I think it still costs too much for what it is so I’m not bothered by the fact that this laptop doesn’t support it. I don’t have any discs anyway. Part of that is just my frugal side coming out though. I’m all about better technology. It just has to be at a good price point before I will dive in.

  3. I just got a brand new Macbook Pro 17″ three days ago. I am happy about everything except the speakers.
    The sound is distorted and on certain frequencies the chassis vibrates. This makes listening to some kinds of music (just to name one: solo piano, either jazz or classical, which tends to have wide dynamics and resonance) almost unbearable.
    Of course I never expected the audio of a laptop to be five-star HiFi; but having owned a MBP 17″ of the previous ‘silver key’ series, I know that things weren’t this bad.
    On my older machine I could listen to anything, even at top volume, with a clean, round, reasonably good sound. The new one in comparison sounds tinny and fuzzy like a giant FM radio.
    I either bought a lemon or there has been a noticeable fall in quality, at least regarding this aspect.

  4. Yah, there’s got to be some software/hardware filter running because as I noticed earlier, it sounds great coming out of the headphone jack into my home stereo but crappy coming out of the HDMI into the same stereo. I have yet to figure it out though.

  5. JOSH!

    Thank you! Exact same story with me. Finally upgraded my old aluminum macbook and have the vibrating chassis. My old macbook was great 🙁 It’s definitely a fail in quality. Mine is a 13 inch. I tested a 13 floor model in the retail store and it was fine.

Comments are closed.

Read previous post:
The Benefits of State Management

When trying to understand someone so you can help them change for the better, you must first know where they...

Close